Pulpit Crimes: The Criminal Mishandling of God’s Word

159925090x01_aa_scmzzzzzzz_v37037465_.jpg I can always count on my dad to get me a great book (or two!) for Christmas, and this year was no exception. It’s taken me longer than it probably should have to read its 150 or so pages, but I have just finished Pulpit Crimes: The Criminal Mishandling of God’s Word, a new title by James R. White.

I recommend this book! If you are in the ministry, especially if you haven’t been “around the block yet” and are still new to your tasks, or if you are hoping to one day be in the ministry, this book contains invaluable details concerning what not to do and say when standing behind that pulpit.

And if you are not in the ministry, I still recommend the book to you. It will certainly help equip you in recognizing what is biblical and what is not from those who are in church leadership, enabling you to better obey the Bible’s commands to both try the spirits and to test all things, holding fast that which is good. Hopefully, though, there is some good, godly leadership in your church already, and Pulpit Crimes will likely make you appreciate that fact all the more!

As Shawn, who was also reading the book last I heard, pointed out, most of the information will be familiar to you if you follow James White’s weblog & netcast, but if you do not, you will enjoy and hopefully benefit from the book.

James begins the book by briefly giving an overview of what that preaching thing is all about. What are pastors to do? What does it mean to stand behind a pulpit and preach? How do man’s ideas of this task line up with what the Bible teaches? These are important questions that should be able to be answered biblically by anyone who stands before the flock and seeks to deliver unto them the Word of God in sermon.

The bulk of this book, as the title suggests, involves what not to do as a preacher. Trying to be as general as possible to make the book less tied to one time period (though if you are familiar with “Christian” television, you’ll recognize some celebrity preachers by their crimes even without their names being given), James describes various ways in which the act of preaching is being misused and abused by those within Christendom.

The “Rap Sheet,” as he calls it, includes the following crimes:

  • “Prostitution” — The exchanging of truth for a lie, motivated by a love of money. This crime is epitomized by the “name it and claim it” movement.
  • “Pandering to Pluralism” — The rejection of vital gospel truths in order to appeal to a wider audience, such as presenting Jesus Christ as one way among many rather than the Way.
  • “Cowardice Under Fire” — Compromising biblical truth or refusing to take a stand for it against the world, leaving the flock with no true protection.
  • “Entertainment Without a License” — Louder music, fancier lights, better bands, and a happier crowd. Leave a few minutes to say a sermonette that fit the entertainment, but make sure it isn’t too long so people don’t get bored after all the excitement of “worship.” As James says, “This is a pulpit crime of immense proportions.” It’s also the reason why I can’t in good conscience watch that “Christian” television station anymore.
  • “Felonious Eisegesis” — Eisegesis, for those who don’t know, involves forcing a meaning into a text that doesn’t belong there, reading one’s opinions into a text, and so on. Regarding the Bible, eisegesis involves silencing the God-breathed Scriptures, supplanting their truth with the doctrines and traditions of man. James pays special attention to those who would try to make homosexuality acceptable by wresting the Scriptures to make it so.
  • “Cross Dressing” — Women behind the pulpit. James examines the biblical evidence, which (leaving eisegesis [see above] out of the equation) plainly says women ought to remain silent in the assemblies. As he says, “There surely is no question, however, that some of the leading heretical teachers in the post-evangelical world today are women, and they have garnered a wide and influential following.”
  • “Pulpit Fiction” — What happens when a preacher becomes a superstar? Just like with Hollywood’s celebrities, personality cults arise, and eventually the superstar preacher falls away from the truth and into diverse errors, even to the point of preaching false gospels.
  • “Body Count” — Church membership, discipline, fellowship, and familiarity is vitally important. Reading this chapter tonight not only made me long for a church home and more consistent Christian fellowship. But it also pointed out the dangers of making an increase in numbers the end itself rather than a side effect of the genuine growth that God causes. This chapter is a cry in the wilderness, and I would recommend the book for it alone.
  • “Identity Theft” — What happens when baptism and the Lord’s Supper no longer resemble their biblical prototypes? What happens when Christians no longer understand the vast and eternal importance of these ordinances of the church? I used to wonder why church discipline was a big deal, but when the communion supper is given its due importance, to be forced by the church to go without it would be punishment. I have never heard the Lord’s Supper described as James has in this book, and I am simply amazed at how naively I have partaken of it in the past and at how little importance, majesty, awe, and reverence accompanied such an amazing event! I’m going to have to include this along with “Body Count” above as being a chapter which is worth the price of the book itself!
  • “Warranty Fraud” — What happens when the gospel is preached in such a shallow, empty way that all it takes to “get saved” is a momentary thought about Jesus, without any regard to genuine faith, sorrowful repentance, continuance in good works, and so on? What happens when it is preached that all it takes is that momentary thought to get one’s “ticket punched” for Heaven, without ever taking care to ensure the person is genuinely saved, without no instruction to them to make their calling and election sure? How many millions are going to Hell clinging to a false hope, a momentary feeling of warm fuzziness brought on by an entertaining (see above) preacher man and his band? James says, “This kind of teaching is not just imbalanced; the Bible identifies it as false and deceptive, and, since it leads many to a false assurance, it is a pulpit crime on the felonious level.”

James concludes the book by asking, “Where are the cops?” What can be done with all of this? Check the book out. Buy one for a friend in seminary, share a copy with your church leadership. Maybe they are doing everything right; if they are, I think this book would be encouraging to them, letting them know that they are on the straight & narrow and that they aren’t abusing their authority as a shepherd to the flock. You’ll probably want to let them know you gave them the book as an encouragement and not to say, “Hey, I couldn’t help but think of you as I read a couple of these chapters; you might want to give it a read!” ;-)

Still on my reading list, in not really any order, are the following:

Also, each of the links to Amazon.com on this page are referral links. If you follow them and purchase any of the books mentioned or anything else on Amazon.com during that shopping session, I’ll get a tiny percentage of that purchase. Whatever I earn from such things goes straight into maintaining Timothy’s Burden by helping to cover web hosting and domain renewals. I greatly appreciate every little bit!

14 thoughts on “Pulpit Crimes: The Criminal Mishandling of God’s Word”

  1. Thanks for the description, Rick! I was really hoping to get this book for Christmas, but it just didn’t happen. So, I’ll have to buy it myself. Along with all the other books that I need/would like. Anywho, thanks again for the description. Although I had a good understanding of what it was about, you gave me a better one. :)

  2. Justin, did you see the link to Defending Your Faith by R.C. Sproul there at the end? You have mentioned a desire to be an apologist, and so the book may very well be useful to you.

  3. I want both the books you mentioned (that is, this book and the one you mentioned in the comment)

    I’ll have to read it and pass it along to my pastors (because they happen to be following all that you outlined…to the best of my knowledge…and I know for sure none of them are women)

  4. I’m halfway through the first book I mentioned in the end-of-post list (The Radical Reformission), and I already would like to recommend it more highly than the book I reviewed above. It’s not only funny and easy to read, but it is thoroughly challenging and comfort-zone thrashing. For a good deal of the New Years party I went to, I was in my own little world reading it and found it very hard to put down each time I got back to it.

  5. What’s it ’bout? Wait, I could probably just click the link and figure it out for myself, couldn’t I?

    Okay, so I checked it out, read the description…and bought two.

    I’ma give one to my boss. It sounds SO good that I can’t afford to not get it.

  6. Regarding the video you linked to, Justin, I didn’t find it so bad. A few changes of the lyrics, and that’d probably be passable. The larger problems I noticed included one of the lady singers teaching prior to the song, a direct violation of Scripture, and the speaker after the singing should be rebuked as well for his theological dimwittery.

  7. Wow, so according to the Atlantic Online, Brigham Young was a more influential character in American history than Jonathan Edwards was. Tear.

  8. Sorry Rick, I won’t spam again.

    Also, I seem to have trouble getting into my account. The “Login” tab has disappeared. Could you help me with that? Please and thank you.

  9. Thanks for the link, I still can’t get to it via the tab. See, what I’m talking about is about at the top, you know, where it says “Blog”, “About”, and “Archives”, the “Register” tab is gone.

    Oh, well, under the “Leave a Reply” sign, I read:
    “Spam will be deleted.
    You’re free to behave foolishly; you’re only making yourself look silly. It’s okay to disagree, especially if you want to strike up some conversation over it. Please try to remain “on topic” with what the blog entry was about. “Off topic” or other miscellaneous banter can be enjoyed over at the Fellowship Hall. Thanks.”

    I thought when it said, “Please… remain on topic”, I thought it was referring to me. I’ve never seen this message before, so I thought you added it in response to my random posts. Sorry for the confusion!

  10. The tab only showed up because I had it set so anyone could register. I turned that option off, so that link disappeared. Just do what I do and bookmark the admin panel. Makes it much easier. :)

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Use your Gravatar-enabled email address while commenting to automatically enhance your comment with some of Gravatar's open profile data.

Comments must be made in accordance with the comment policy. This site uses Akismet to reduce spam; learn how your comment data is processed.

You may use Markdown to format your comments; additionally, these HTML tags and attributes may be used: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

the Rick Beckman archive
Scroll to Top