Can Atheists and Christians Coexist?

Sev­en­teen years ago, if you were to ask me “Can athe­ists and Chris­tians coex­ist?” I would’ve said one of two things: “no” or the more smart-ass “every­one on the plan­et exists at the same time just fine so yes.” My smart-allecky past self aside, let’s focus on that “no” response.

Sev­en­teen years ago, I was a *inhales* inde­pen­dent fun­da­men­tal Bap­tist who strong­ly believed in the ple­nary ver­bal inspi­ra­tion of the Holy Bible and the inerran­cy there­of, in the King James Ver­sion alone, nat­u­ral­ly. I was a lot. But one thing that I decid­ed­ly was not was a peace­mak­er. Bridg­ing gaps was­n’t some­thing that came up much at my back­woods lit­tle coun­try church. Indeed, most activ­i­ties seemed direct­ed toward either get­ting butts into the seats or, well, mak­ing sure every­one knew of all the peo­ple we did­n’t approve of.

Homo­sex­u­als, athe­ists, Catholics, Mus­lims, Mor­mons, etc. etc. I recall the youth pas­tor even mak­ing a snide remark about a vis­it­ing evan­ge­list hap­pen­ing to be Black because appar­ent­ly even race was a divi­sive issue at my church. 

Dur­ing my time at that church, I was intro­duced to the movie Apoc­a­lypse and its three sequels. For being low-bud­get movies that were, I think, financed by Chris­t­ian groups, they were at least mod­er­ate­ly watch­able and fea­tured a few sur­prise appear­ance by actors like Gary Busey, Howie Man­del, and Mr. T. Detail­ing the events of a pret­ribu­la­tion­al, pre­mil­len­ni­al End Times frame­work, the series fol­lows a vari­ety of peo­ple liv­ing in a post-Rap­ture world ruled by the Antichrist. Those who came to believe in Jesus were called out as “haters,” out­cast and per­se­cut­ed by a world that can­not tol­er­ate their message.

Sev­en­teen years ago, that’s how it felt to be a Chris­t­ian, at least my par­tic­u­lar kind of Chris­t­ian. Chris­tians could­n’t pos­si­bly be haters because the very act of warn­ing peo­ple about their sins — homo­sex­u­al­i­ty includ­ed — was seen as a com­plete act of com­pas­sion. Chris­tians weren’t the haters… Every­one else was. They hat­ed God, they hat­ed holy things, they hat­ed holy peo­ple. There­fore, it fol­lowed that when the world was giv­en over to the Antichrist and the major­i­ty of the world was firm­ly on his side that Chris­tians would be derid­ed as being hateful.

Coex­is­tence did­n’t seem possible.

The very thought of it felt dirty, actu­al­ly. “What fel­low­ship has light with dark­ness?” I would have argued back then. 

What the Bible actu­al­ly said, though, rarely fac­tored into my deci­sions or the deci­sions, as I’ve grown to learn, of my church and oth­ers like it.

I’m an athe­ist now, and like my time as a Chris­t­ian before, I spent the bet­ter part of my first years as an unbe­liev­er being a divi­sive butthead, doing every­thing I could to “dis­prove” Chris­tian­i­ty or show the Bible to be worth­less. It occurs to me, then, that I can­not blame Chris­tian­i­ty for my hate­ful­ness before. I did­n’t leave it behind when I left the church behind; it was some­thing with­in me that I had to overcome.

In so doing, I’ve reached the point where I don’t care if there is a Chris­t­ian church on every oth­er street cor­ner. Frankly, that does­n’t mat­ter. What I’d like to see, though, are bet­ter Chris­tians who aren’t out there mak­ing the same mis­takes I made. 

As a Chris­t­ian, I could­n’t imag­ine liv­ing peace­ful­ly, or coex­ist­ing, with homo­sex­u­als or those who con­doned (or received) abor­tions. Imag­ine my sur­prise when I real­ized that the Bible does­n’t con­demn those things! As a mat­ter of fact, a lot of what the church­es spend their time on has lit­tle to do with the book they claim to stand upon, and a whole lot of what the book actu­al­ly calls upon Chris­tians to do is rarely found among “God’s peo­ple” today.

As an athe­ist, I chose to become a human­ist, some­one who cares about the wel­fare of my fel­low humans. The more I leaned into it, the more I real­ized that this world­view was­n’t incom­pat­i­ble with Chris­tian­i­ty. Well, not bib­li­cal, Jesus-dri­ven Chris­tian­i­ty.

I would glad­ly accept every gospel mes­sage direct­ed toward me if it came from the lips of a Chris­t­ian who was tru­ly tak­ing up his or her cross in devo­tion to not only their god but their fel­low humans, as direct­ed by their Lord in their book.

Can athe­ists and Chris­tians coex­ist? Hypo­thet­i­cal­ly, and ide­al­ly, yes. I believe so. 

It won’t, how­ev­er, come easy. Not every Chris­t­ian cares a whit about what Jesus taught; many pre­fer instead to get hung up on a hand­ful of more open-to-inter­pre­ta­tion Bible vers­es in order to jus­ti­fy some big­otry or, more sin­is­ter­ly, to sup­plant Jesus’ teach­ings with a hol­low shell of a reli­gion that func­tions as lit­tle more than a social club.

And then there are the athe­ists. Many don’t care one way or anoth­er, but among those who pub­licly claim the athe­ist label, folks all too often fall into the trap of set­ting them­selves on a mis­sion to dis­rupt reli­gion, whether by protests or memes, often ill-spirited. 

Athe­ists and Chris­tians can coex­ist, but for it to hap­pen, we’re all going to have to be bet­ter.

Bet­ter Jesus-followers.

Bet­ter humanists.

Bet­ter humans.

I believe in us.

0 thoughts on “Can Atheists and Christians Coexist?”

  1. Pingback: Why Is There Something Rather Than Nothing? - Resolutely, Rick

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Use your Gravatar-enabled email address while commenting to automatically enhance your comment with some of Gravatar's open profile data.

Comments must be made in accordance with the comment policy. This site uses Akismet to reduce spam; learn how your comment data is processed.

You may use Markdown to format your comments; additionally, these HTML tags and attributes may be used: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

Rick Beckman